Civicus 8th World Assembly
    United Nations Europe Africa Latin America   Home Subscription About us  
   
[PT] [ES]
 
   
   1/26/2009 Print Send e-m@il
 

“Right time to develop free media,” say campaigners
By Rahul Kumar

Activists are looking at the constructive side of the global economic meltdown. Media activists at the World Social Forum (WSF-2009) taking place at Belem, Brazil, say the crisis has provided a historic opportunity to strengthen the free media movement because the mainstream media has colluded with the corporate world in bringing the worldwide financial chaos upon everyone.

 
  Ignacio Ramonet / Photo Paulo Amorim  
Speaking at a panel discussion on Monday, just a day before the formal inauguration of the WSF, Altamiro Borges of the Vermelho association said: "The bulk of the media organisations are guilty for the crisis as most of them supported the conditions that lead to the meltdown. The mass media played an important role in maintaining and furthering the hegemony of the corporates."

Echoing similar views, Ignacio Ramonet, former director of Le Monde Diplomatique said the great private groups have been weakened by the economic crisis. Neo-liberalism has received a deathly stroke and the power of the media, specially the written media, is weakening. He added: "The decay of the big media has been caused due to its alliance with the financial circles and the fact that they also used similar methods of functioning."


The speakers reflected on the coverage of the meltdown and found grave lapses in reporting facts. Bernardo Kucinski from the University of Sao Paulo said the media portrayed the crisis with an alarmist tendency and chose to hide the truth. "Banks in Brazil had created economic analysis departments which cultivated certain journalists and fed information only to them. This group of people, in collaboration with the journalists, tried to divert attention from the economic chaos to other issues. Ironically, the best coverage of the crisis came in US newspapers, which even covered the political links of the crisis", said Kucinski.


The discussion looked critically at funding which is crucial for sustaining free media organisations, apart from the challenges posed by corporates and governments from time to time. Most of the free and alternative media organizations thrive online as well as in the form of community radio stations. Jonas Valente from Intervozes said that free media is a necessity in the present world order because it promotes human rights and provides a diversity of voices to its consumers. "In Brazil, the commercial media is just six networks which control over 90 per cent of the market. Those who produce their own information find it difficult to present their views to the people. The 180 million people of Brazil need a more democratic environment," lamented Valente.


Giving examples of harassment of the free media organizations, Jose Soter of the Brazilian Association of Community Radio (ABRACO) said that the authorities closed down eight community radio stations in Belem, where the WSF is being organised with help from the government, on the grounds that the spectrum had to be cleaned.


Similarly, highlighting the hurdles that the corporate media create for smaller organizations, Renato Rovai from the Revista Forum said: "Someone complained that community radio stations can knock down planes from the sky. The mainstream media calls bloggers monkeys. Then we had a Sao Paulo newspaper accusing us of taking public sector advertisements to run our establishment. The fact is that the mainstream media also cannot survive without government advertisements. Basically, they do not want us to access finances. Therefore we need to have new avenues for financing."


The discussion on funds for the free media had the most divergent views among the free media activists. Some wanted government money to be tapped while others did not agree; some felt only people's money should be used and others debated if newer models of funding could be created. Ivana Bentes from the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro strongly felt that the alternative media organisations should look beyond the state as a provider.


Maria Pia Matta, head of the Latin American branch of AMARC, the World Association of Community Radio Broadcasters, urged governments to advance the right to communication as a human right. She said: "Bolivia and some other countries in Latin America have acknowledged that community radio is also a right to communication and have said so through their Constitution. Maybe we should form alliances with the governments and political parties so that the movement can be strengthened and advanced."


On the way forward, Joaquim Constanzo, the IPS Latin-America director said: "We should aspire to fight the big media in their own domain. However important the Internet may be, I do not think we can fight the big ones with small constructions. We need both the technology and the content to fight the big media."


Agreeing with Constanzo, Borges added that if the free media movement has to take on the big media, it will need good quality professionals and also urge the government to define public policies that allow alternative and free media to flourish.


Matta advocated that if the governments treated frequency as a common heritage, it would radically alter the community radio movement. Experts were in favour of using digital networks, already being used by over a billion users, to further widened the free media movement


 
       
       
 
TERRAVIVA TV  
 
The WSF in pictures
more videos
   
Pdfs
Download PDF File
Download PDF File
   
Partners  
Interviews
 
'Crisis Could Lead to 'Revolutionary Change'
As the economic crisis bites deeper, a revolutionary outcome may be possible, in the view of French academic Alain Bihr. An interview by Gustavo Capdevila in Zurich.
'We Have to be Good at Proposing, Not Just Opposing'
Aye Aye Win director of Dignity International was interviewed by IPS Editor-in-Chief about the role of the WSF today.
Not a Static Platform
The WSF's relevance lies on its capacity to "suggest clear socialist alternatives to defeat the imperialist monster" says Onyango Oloo, organizer of the Forum in Kenya. An interview by IPS' Terna Guyse
Irfan Mufti: 'NGOs are part of the problem'
In Pakistan, NGOs are taking people away from politics, says Irfan Mufti, interviewed by IPS' Zofeen Ibrahim in Karachi.
'The Forum must come up with answers to the crisis'
The WSF must evolve to avoid repeating itself, especially in this when capitalism is crmbling, says French agronomist and activist Henri Rouillé d'Orfeuil, interviewed in Chile by Daniela Estrada.
   
Columns  
Historical challenge
The capitalist crisis and five presidents gathering in Belem, attest to the big challenge before this Forum: become an effective global force for change, says TerraViva editor Alejandro Kirk.
Story of An Indian Lost in Brazil
Journalist Rahul Kumar travelled all the way from India to find out that he looks local in the Amazonian region, where heat and mangoes resemble home.
Gallery  
27 Jan
  IPS TerraViva is an independent publication of IPS – Inter Press Service news agency. The opinions expressed in TerraViva do not necessarily reflect the editorial views or the official position of any of the sponsors. IPS gratefully acknowledges the generous support of Oxfam Novib and ActionAid.